Get the right protection for the best price


Call Now
Learn More
no cost, no pressure

Insurance Quotes

Homeowners Insurance

Fast, comprehensive quotes with multiple top-rated carriers instantly!


Automotive Insurance

Chances are, you’re probably overpaying for your car insurance. That’s why we offer the Best Rate Guarantee.


Business Insurance

We want to have the confidence that the business you’ve built is covered by a company that understands your business insurance needs.


Life Insurance

We can work with you to find the plan that will ensure that you and your family have a life line without breaking your budget.


Flood Insurance

It is possible to find all of the protection you need for your property. Get a quote and get piece of mind.

Don’t see what you need?


A local landmark for nearly half a century, the John Hill Agency is an independent, family-owned and operated insurance agency that has served both residents and business owners in the community since 1959. It was established by John Hill in 1959 and continues to be managed by his son, J. Michael Hill – whose mission is to deliver the same personalized, superior service on which the company was founded.

From the community

  • John Hill Agency was so helpful in assisting us with purchasing homeowners insurance when we were dropped by our former insurance company after Super Storm Sandy. They were always pleasant when receiving my numerous phone calls regarding rates, coverage’s, etc.
    Patricia K. – Bayville, NJ
  • I have had both home and auto insurance with the John Hill Agency since I moved here in 1999. I am happy to say that they are very courteous and efficient, whether it was on the phone or in their office. It is a pleasure to do business with them.
    Susan S. – Bayville, NJ
  • We have insured our very first home with you just three years ago. The staff has been wonderful and very helpful!! Before my marriage and moving out of state, I had been with John Hill Agency for over 20 years. Your agency is just as good now as it was then. That is why I returned.
    Ron and Jean C. – Lanoka Harbor, NJ

Have a question about a new or existing policy?

Just ask!
John Hill Agency Logo


The John Hill Agency office is open for clients, pending direction from the NJ Government. Due to COVID, we have put into place a number of precautions for the safety of our staff and clients.

Thank you & stay safe!