insurance Agency serving Bayville New Jersey

We Make Insurance Easy!

Get the right business, homeowners, and auto insurance at the best price.

Contractor holding plans in an office setting

We're here to help you save on insurance. Interested?

Compare multiple rates from leading companies in one place. 

Over 60 Years Of Insurance Solutions

A local landmark for nearly half a century, the John Hill Agency is an independent, family-owned and operated insurance agency that has served both residents and business owners in the community since 1959. It was established by John Hill in 1959 and continues to be managed by his son, J. Michael Hill – whose mission is to deliver the same personalized, superior service on which the company was founded.

We don't sell you a policy,
we find the best one for you.

Personal Insurance

Get the right homeowners, auto and umbrella policies to protect you and your family.

Business Insurance

Get the right business insurance policies to protect you, your business, and employees

Niche Insurance

Specialized services for those that require additonal attention to their insurance portfolios.

YouTube video
  • Fast Quoting

    We know time is always of the essence which is why we work efficiently to service each client.

  • Personal Service

    Each client has a different risk profile, and thus, gets personalized attention & customer service.

  • Claims Advocacy

    Insurance is meant to protect us and we're here when you need us the most - at the time of a claim.

Have questions about the process of switching to us?

Get answers to some frequently asked questions below.

There are many reasons we feel that we're a great choice to help with your insurance. Maybe the biggest one is that our agency is 100% independent and can offer you many choices when it comes to coverage and insurance providers. This saves you hours of time in trying to compare the different options yourself 🙂

When you're ready to switch over to our agency, you'll first need to secure coverage with the carrier we found for you. This usually involves making an initial down payment and signing off on the policies we present to you. The process is very simple and only takes a matter of minutes.

While we can definitely revisit your policies on an annual basis, changing insurance carriers every year (or six months) can actually negatively impact your "insurance score" which can actually cause your rates to increase. Therefore, while it's possible, we don't necessarily recommend it.

team meeting at desk talking

Let's talk insurance

We take the hassle out of finding the perfect insurance plan for you. Start a conversation to find out how!

  • Start Online

    Enter some basic information on our website to start.

  • We Shop For You

    We closely review your current policy, checking for coverage levels and exclusions with our multiple carriers.

  • Pick The Best Plan

    Choose the coverage package that fits best.