“We have insured our very first home with you just three years ago. The staff has been wonderful and very helpful!! Before my marriage and moving out of state, I had been with John Hill Agency for over 20 years. Your agency is just as good now as it was then. That is why I returned.”
Ron and Jean C. – Lanoka Harbor, NJ

“The John Hill Agency is a very friendly and professional insurance agency. It is great to have this kind of service in our neighborhood.”
Tim K. – Ocean Gate, NJ

“I have had both home and auto insurance with the John Hill Agency since I moved here in 1999. I am happy to say that they are very courteous and efficient, whether it was on the phone or in their office. It is a pleasure to do business with them.”
Susan S. – Bayville, NJ

“John Hill Agency was so helpful in assisting us with purchasing homeowners insurance when we were dropped by our former insurance company after Super Storm Sandy. They were always pleasant when receiving my numerous phone calls regarding rates, coverage’s, etc.”
Patricia K. – Bayville, NJ

“I would like to thank John Hill Agency for their kindness and professionalism, insuring my home on such short notice is greatly appreciated.”

Robert C. – Forked River, NJ

“John Hill Agency was friendly and polite in the extreme. They were very thorough and helpful. I would not hesitate to recommend them to any prospective customers I might happen to come across.”
Anthony R. – Hackensack, NJ

“John Hill Agency has gone above and beyond their responsibility to help me get house insurance. I changed insurance companies because my old company would not return my phone calls to renew my policy. Now I am saving money with better coverage. And my old insurance company is calling me every other day for me to get back to them. Now I am not calling them back.”
Burt M. – Toms River, NJ

“Thank you so much for listening to our plight and helping us get property insurance when no other agency would sell insurance to us.”
Albert and Rosemary S. – Toms River, NJ

“I would highly recommend The John Hill Agency to anyone who needs insurance. They found me the best policy for my individual needs. It’s nice to deal with a local agency who really understands its clients!”
Courtenay S. – Bayville, NJ

“Just a note to say how impressed I was with my recent insurance purchase at your agency. Our agent was very knowledgeable, friendly, informative and courteous. She made the process very swift and easy. Thank you.”
Holly S. – Bayville, NJ

“I was so pleased when I contacted John Hill Agency. They were so knowledgeable and gave me all the answers I needed within a few minutes. Our agent was extremely pleasant and so easy to work with. Other companies had not given me quotes for a week at a time. I will highly recommend John Hill Agency. It was such a pleasure working with them.”
Vincent and Laura M. – Bayville, NJ

“It was an absolute pleasure to deal with Gale Carnevale. The transition of both my car insurance and homeowners insurance was so smooth. Gale was very professional and efficient. I look forward to working with Gale and The John Hill Agency. I will not hesitate to recommend friends and family to contact Gale for their insurance needs.”
Susan B. – Bayville, NJ

Have a question about a new or existing policy?

Just Ask!
John Hill Agency Logo


The John Hill Agency office is open for clients, pending direction from the NJ Government. Due to COVID, we have put into place a number of precautions for the safety of our staff and clients.

Thank you & stay safe!